The article critiques the efficacy of elections in fostering democracy, highlighting significant global challenges in 2024 that often resulted in authoritarianism and violence. It argues for a shift towards empowering citizens through alternative democratic processes rather than reliance on traditional elections. Experts suggest innovative governance approaches to restore public engagement and trust in democracy.
In contemplating the onset of the new year, I propose an unconventional resolution: to abandon the practice of participating in elections. There exists a growing sentiment that the considerable investment of resources, time, and faith in electoral systems does not yield tangible improvements in our communities or broader society. This notion stems from the stark reality unveiled in 2024, a year that saw over 70 countries conducting elections amidst significant global turmoil. Rather than advancing democracy, these elections often exacerbated the rise of authoritarian regimes and incited violence, leading to public disillusionment.
The central thesis articulated by Josh Lerner, co-executive director of People Powered, resonates deeply: “Our obsession with elections is killing democracy.” The report by Freedom House highlighted alarming instances where electoral processes served merely as instruments of oppression—22 elections witnessed attempts to jail or disqualify opponents, while 26 contests were marred by violence. In Mexico, candidates faced assassination attempts, while violent electoral manipulation characterized situations in countries like Venezuela under Nicolás Maduro’s regime.
Notably, the phenomenon of the “sore winner” emerged, wherein ruling parties exploited their victories to undermine oppositional voices, as evidenced by actions taken in Georgia and Mexico. Although some optimistic narratives circulated, celebrating peaceful transfers of power in select nations, the overall context revealed that power changes frequently resulted in increased civil unrest. In South Korea, a failed coup attempt highlighted the consequential strife following political victories.
Experts are urging a reevaluation of how we conceptualize democracy beyond the ballot box. Leonora Camner of Democracy Without Elections emphasized this shift, advocating for the establishment of democratic processes that enhance citizen empowerment. Notably, Matt Leighninger from the National Civic League proposed transformational alternatives such as citizens’ assemblies, participatory budgeting, and comprehensive civic engagement reforms. These democratic innovations are vital for fostering citizen involvement and restoring faith in governance.
As 2024 closes, it becomes increasingly evident that to revitalize democracy, a departure from traditional election-centric models is imperative. The salvation of democratic principles necessitates a shift in focus from elections to fostering tangible civic engagement and inclusiveness. By cultivating democratic infrastructure and enhancing the public’s ability to influence governance, society can reclaim the very essence of democracy—government that resonates with and empowers the populace.
The commentary reflects on the widespread disillusionment with electoral processes observed globally in 2024, a year marked by significant electoral activity yet accompanied by increased authoritarianism and public unrest. With over 4 billion individuals participating in elections, expectations for democratic progress were thwarted as many contests became vehicles for oppression rather than empowerment. The analysis urges a rethinking of how democracy is defined and practiced, advocating for direct civic engagement rather than reliance on conventional elections.
In conclusion, the events of 2024 illuminate the pressing need to reassess our commitment to traditional electoral processes. The evidence suggests that elections may contribute more to division and disenfranchisement than true democratic empowerment. By championing alternative models of governance that prioritize citizen engagement over electoral victories, society can foster a more meaningful and inclusive democratic process. This evolution is essential for reinstating public trust in governmental institutions and promoting a governance structure that truly represents and serves its constituents.
Original Source: www.vcstar.com
