This article analyzes how Benni McCarthy’s strategic substitutions and formations improved Harambee Stars’ performance, resulting in a 3-3 draw against The Gambia in their World Cup qualifier. McCarthy’s approach signifies a potential transformation in Kenyan football, moving from a traditionally defensive style to a more dynamic and offensive strategy.
A new chapter for Harambee Stars commenced at the Stade Olympique Alassane Ouattara in Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, with the appointment of former South African international Benni McCarthy. His challenge began in a 2026 FIFA World Cup qualifier against Johnathan McKinstry, who has guided The Gambian national team to recent success with two consecutive FKF Premier League titles. This tactical analysis explains how McCarthy’s strategy and substitutions facilitated a hard-fought 3-3 draw against The Gambia.
Kenya adopted a 1-4-2-3-1 formation, featuring Ian Otieno in goal, flanked by fullbacks Erick ‘Marcelo’ Ouma and Rooney Onyango. The defense comprised Danish defender Daniel Anyembe at left center back and the eagerly anticipated return of Brian Mandela at right center back. The midfield was reinforced by Anthony Akumu, Ismael Gonzalez, and Richard Odada, while Michael Olunga led the front line, supported by John Avire and Eric Johana.
In contrast, McKinstry utilized a 1-5-2-3 formation in anticipation of a transformed Kenyan side, deviating from their traditionally defensive style. Gambia, coming off a string of nine goals conceded in four matches, relied on Brighton and Hove Albion’s Yakuba Minteh and Al-Taawoun’s Musa Barrow for offensive support. This tactical shift allowed Gambia to threaten without sacrificing defensive solidity.
During the match, Kenya sought to control the game by initially setting up a 2-4-4 structure from goal kicks, aiming for collective play progression. However, the midfield connection faltered, hampering effective transitions between defensive and attacking phases. Consequently, Olunga and Avire struggled to receive the ball, limiting their offensive contributions.
Gambia played strategically, allowing Kenya’s center backs to control the ball while springing into action in wide areas. Their midblock was notably organized, employing a 5-4-1 setup that pressured Kenya’s midfield. Despite some successful wide combinations from the Kenyans, Olunga missed opportunities, and Gambia capitalized on defensive gaps, including winning a penalty after a foul by goalkeeper Otieno.
In the second half, McCarthy responded by introducing winger William Lenkupae, prompting a reshuffle where Eric Johana transitioned into an attacking midfield position. Following a brilliant strike from Barrow that put Gambia ahead, Kenya struggled defensively, unable to maintain cohesion at the back.
As the match progressed, McCarthy introduced Jonah Ayunga and Mohammed Bajaber, shifting to a 4-4-2 formation with Olunga and Ayunga upfront. This change led to immediate results, as Olunga drew a penalty that he subsequently converted, narrowing Gambia’s lead. The adjustments created more offensive opportunities as Bajaber scored, equalizing the game.
With moments remaining, Kenya intensified their efforts, leading to a chaotic long throw that allowed Lenkupae to slot home, resulting in a thrilling 3-3 draw. Coach Benni McCarthy’s tactical expertise shone through, signaling the potential end of the “dull” Harambee Stars and a brighter future for Kenyan football.
In summary, Benni McCarthy’s tactical choices and substitutions proved pivotal in transforming Harambee Stars’ performance against The Gambia. Through strategic formation changes and player adjustments, Kenya managed to secure a resilient 3-3 draw. The match exemplified a potential shift in Kenyan football, moving away from a defensive mindset and showcasing tactical sophistication under McCarthy’s guidance.
Original Source: www.mozzartsport.co.ke
